Search This Blog

About Me

My photo
Memphis, Tennessee, United States
Small town paralegal in the city. Once ran a law office, now being run by one. Med mal defense litigation. I think it's growing on me.

Monday, August 31, 2009

Jerks in the Workplace

Let me first admit that I don't have much experience in this area. I am fortunate enough to have an amazing supervising attorney who, though he probably doesn't realize it, is a great manager of people. That being said, every time I read through a paralegal textbook or open a paralegal magazine, I seem to find the same advice regarding the apparently inevitable bad supervising attorney.

To be clear, I've never personally experienced the bad supervising attorney, but he (or she) is supposedly rude, overbearing, and demanding. He or she treats nonattorney staff and probably everyone else... poorly. It is likely the bad supervisor is either a newbie and completely insecure about her place on the imaginary totem pole, or extremely experienced and has gotten away with the bad attitude for far too long for anyone to expect him to change.

Whichever one of these guys you run into, conventional wisdom seems to be "just deal with it." I heard of a situation recently in which a highly experienced paralegal described performing a task her attorney told her to do, only to have him yell at her later for doing it. Apparently the instructions he gave were ambiguous or not clearly stated. Suffice it to say, what he meant to instruct her to do and what she read were two different things. Rather than explain to him in a courteous and professional manner that there was a misunderstanding (so that such errors could be avoided in the future), she held her tongue and apologized. For what? I ask. For not reading his mind? For the sake of his ego? For fear of losing her job? No purpose is served by allowing your supervising attorney to believe something that is not true about your judgment and skills. If you have spent years working at something, giving it all your effort, you should not have to cower at your place of business. If anyone expects this, there is a major flaw in the system of your profession. Perhaps I am idealistic. Perhaps I can afford to say these things because I have a stellar Boss. Still, there is something wrong with that picture.

In my own paralegal text books, I came across various hypothetical situations where the correct answer was simply to accept the subordinate role and apologize profusely. Now, in matters of law, I am in complete agreement with the subordinate role. You won't ever catch me telling my Boss that my legal judgment is better than his. First, it just wouldn't be true. Second, even if it were, it wouldn't be my place to tell him so. However, in matters of basic management and administration, the only thing my Boss has on me is years of experience. There is no business management license that will suddenly allow one to manage a business. There is no administration license that suddenly allows someone to perform administrative duties in a business. This is not to say that I regularly exercise insubordination, nor would I. In my case, I have a lot of respect for my supervising attorney as a lawyer, a Boss, and a person. If I didn't, I would not be working for him. If he were a regular jerk, things would be different.

The first thing that would change is my job. Upon understanding that I had a bad boss, if I were working at the small firm I am now, I would immediately begin a job search. I know what you're thinking... what if the only lawfirms in your area all drink from the same water cooler? Well, if you try a few firms out and they all appear to employ snotty, horrible people, you can a) move (I know of some great attorneys around here... but don't even think about trying to move in on my job) or b) give up on the paralegal profession entirely. Luckily, as in most other fields, jerksters are the exception, not the rule, so you shouldn't have to resort to plan b.

In a bigger firm, the issue may be more complicated. But you never have to meekly accept disrespect and rude behavior from an attorney with whom you are working. It is my understanding that larger firms usually have supervising partners who govern associates and sometimes paralegals. It is also my understanding that larger firms usually have human resource departments. Before accepting that you will have to duck to avoid flying pens every day, or that you will have to bow before a daily dose of arrogant suggestions ( "Did you think I wouldn't want coffee this morning?"), I highly suggest approaching someone in a true management position to a) alert them of the situation and b) ask for tips on how to handle this person. Obviously, this should not be done to "rat out" the bad seed, but rather to give HR a heads up. If done in a professional and mature manner, such action can encourage management to take subtle action. It can also alert them to patterns of behavior that may be caused by something more than a superiority complex - drugs, alcohol abuse or depression for example.

This advice goes for any job actually. Bad managers don't deserve good employees. When I was a senior in highschool, I was a hostess at a restaurant. We were having a particularly bad night when our manager came to the hostess stand and started pitching a true fit. He threw his notebook across the room and yelled at us in front of a crowd of customers. I did not walk out, though I wanted to very badly; rather, I quietly started preparing to leave the job. No burnt bridges, no more bad boss. Criticism, I can take. Guidance is necessary. Though I've never experienced it, discipline may sometimes be needed. But rudeness, haughtiness and superiority complexes from someone in a supervisory role? No thank you.

If you are working hard and are competent at your job, you should not have to accept disrespect from people with whom you work. If you have a job where this is the status quo, for your sake, please start looking for a new one. It is not good for the individual, for the paralegal profession, for the legal field, or for the business world in general, to accept and thereby promote haughty/bad/rude behavior from attorneys, or anyone, for that matter, who is in some sort of supervisory role.

I suppose I break tradition when I say these things. Perhaps I'm too insubordinate for my own good. But come what may, I respect myself and my chosen profession. I am no one's doormat. And neither are you.

Saturday, August 29, 2009

Team Work at the Law Firm

I was recently asked to phrase my blog in less of a lawyer v. paralegal style with a better focus on the fact that we are all on the same team. This entry, therefore, includes hints and tips which will in fact make the practice of law a team event.

Go to court with your attorney. Every firm is different, but even if you ask to attend a trial and the answer is "no" you have at least shown interest and given the decision-makers a reason to think about it. Just be prepared if the answer is yes. The office dress code may be a bit more casual than that of the court. Also, courts differ on where paralegals may sit when accompanying attorneys to a trial. I have heard that a few states will allow paralegals to sit beside the attorneys at the table, but the vast majority of courts will require you to sit with the public. No matter where you sit, though, being in the courtroom during a trial can give you valuable experience, and every once in awhile, it's just plain cool.

Sit in meetings with your attorney. Again, every firm is different, but perhaps your attorney has never thought of having you in a client meeting. Ask. One of the attorney speakers at a recent conference I attended stated that it is a mistake for lawyers to conduct initial client meetings without their assistants. The reason he gave is that the lawyer takes in information by calculating legal angles and gathering the necessary information for such. The paralegal is more inclined to be thinking about what vital statistic information he needs to draft documents or get information from third parties (social security numbers, release forms, contact information, etc.).

While I have never asked to sit in a client meeting, it is not because I don't think it would be helpful but rather because of lack of space and time. I could probably attend the meeting, but then that is taking up time that I could be working on discovery or making calls while the Boss is busy. In our office, it makes more sense to me that I am working on something different while the Boss is conducting his meetings. Also, our office is nice, but small. If the Boss were meeting with one person, it might be intimidating for that person to have both of us sitting in the meeting. And if he were meeting with more than one, there would be no room for another warm body anyway.

Become competent in everything you can do so that your attorney can focus especially on those tasks only he can do. I have said it before, and here I've said it again. While the attorney should be able to do all the things you do, he shouldn't have to. Learn how to effectively research and stay on top of the best search practices. Know procedure, so that when a client calls for an update, you can give her dates to look forward to. I get calls all the time, especially right after I send a status letter with a notice of service, asking what happens next. They are not usually looking for a legal answer but rather for the next step, the next important date on the calendar. A client's matter will usually feel urgent to him, so letting him know that the defendant has thirty days to answer, and that we will not be able to move forward until we receive the answer or reach the expiration of the thirty days, will help ease his mind.

Do it right the first time. Sometimes I am tempted, especially when I've been staring at a computer screen for several hours, to just hand a rough draft of a complaint or brief or motion to the Boss and let him figure out what to edit. However, this won't save anyone time, and it won't save the client money. I take a deep breath and perhaps a five minute break before diving back into the issue. When I finally give the document to my attorney for review, I have overlooked it at least twice. He will still inevitably want to change my wording here or there, and sometimes he finds a blatant copy-paste error I've missed, but if I have taken my time and put forth all my effort, he is usually satisfied with the draft I bring to him.

Be the go-to person. Every team needs someone they can rely on for almost anything that needs to be done, just in case. This kind of fits into being proficient at all tasks nonattorneys can do, but here we're taking it a step further. Be willing to take on any project, large or small. Or at least don't act as if you are above it. If you feel like your talents and skills are not being utilized, or if you feel like your billables aren't being met because you've been asked to make copies twelve times today, approach it from that angle of "I'm not going to be able to meet my billables" rather than "This is not in my job description." If your supervising attorney keeps sending you to pour his coffee, perhaps you should ask her nicely if she wouldn't be better served by using you in a more substantive capacity. (Personally, I would probably ask her if she wouldn't be better served by getting her own coffee, but I realize that not every lawyer is as self-sufficient as mine.)

Demand team work. Or at least subtly demand it. If you have a secretary, utilize him to the best of his abilities. If you are about to work on a nonbillable task, ask yourself if you could delegate it to him. Talk to everyone at the firm, make them all your friends, find someone in each role you can use as an emergency resource or for uplifting discussion. Don't associate with only those individuals at your "level." Team work requires mutual respect and positive thinking from everyone in every role. Being "above" someone in the ancient hierarchial system does not exempt you from treating that person with respect and expecting the best they have to give. That means that the people "above" you are not exempt either. Perform as if you assume everyone on the team knows this, and if they don't already, they should eventually come around.

So there you have it, my six tips for teamwork. Let me know how they work.

Friday, August 28, 2009

Does Nonlawyer = Incompetent?

In my unrivaled wisdom and all-encompassing knowledge, or perhaps in my efforts to over-generalize a bigger issue, I have reduced the types of people who work as nonlawyer legal staff into three distinct groups. Please see below for details.

The Easies These are the individuals working at the law firm not for the clients or the law, but for the cushy office job. They include everyone from highschool students who come in to run documents in the afternoons or over the summer, to young adults who have not figured out their true career aspirations, to part-timers who need the job but not necessarily the money. They take jobs as runners and receptionists, secretaries and file clerks. Many times, the job is simply a paycheck for a temporary period of time, and they tend to treat it as such. They are not to be confused with the runners, receptionists, secretaries, and file clerks who take their jobs seriously and are committed and competent employees - I will address them in a moment.

The Inbetweens These employees can be divided into two subsets: those moving up and those stepping down. The employees moving up are using their legal staff position as some sort of leverage into a new area. Perhaps they intend to go to law school or want to gain legal experience to take with them to the corporate world. Whatever their purpose, they are using the job as a learning and networking tool. Since they are committed to moving up some type of ladder, these individuals will likely be competent, helpful, and smart. Those stepping down are getting ready for retirement, but have not let go of the working world yet. As experienced careermen, they enjoy the interesting legal work, but are not looking to climb any ladders. Their backgrounds tend to be diverse. They will be competent because they just are. After thirty plus years in the career world, it is in their blood to do a job and do it right.

The Career Staffers These people are serious about their jobs. They enjoy the law, working in the law, reading law, aiding attorneys in the practical application of the law, etc. They also fill many of the same positions the Easies fill: secretary, receptionist, file clerk, paralegal. The difference is, these individuals do a better job because they want to be there doing it. This is my current niche, and I know there are plenty of us out there. Because these individuals are serious about their roles in their firms, they are competent and keep themselves educated on important topics. Their goals include great client service, efficiency, and results. They are smart, loyal, and hardworking. They have standards, whether those held by the professional organizations they belong to, or those they hold within themselves. A smart lawyer will have at least one of these people by her side.

One problem I have recently faced is that the Easies have a negative effect on the perception of the Career Staffers. Just today I participated in a conversation with an attorney who was describing the lack of organizational skills of some legal staff he works with. When I asked why they are so disorganized in general, his response was something to the effect of "Well, they're nonlawyers and didn't have proper training." While I would agree that lack of training in basic organization could be a problem, the fact that these people are "nonlawyers" should have little to do with their organizational skills. (I know for a fact that they didn't offer Organizational Skills for Lawyers 101 when my Boss was in law school.) Still, the incompetence of some of the Easies (not all, of course) is giving the rest of us a bad name.

Lawyers, if your legal staff, especially your paralegals, are highly unorganized or incompetent, it has nothing to do with the lack of a law degree. Perhaps you need to figure out which group they fall into. If you need someone with motivation to do a job and do it well, don't hire an Easy. However, if you just need a body to fill up eight hours in the day, be my guest. Further, if you do not feel that you can use your paralegals for researching, analyzing and synthesizing case law, drafting motions, and corresponding with clients in a professional manner, then you have the wrong paralegals. I read somewhere that highly skilled paralegals with a certain level of experience should be able to perform associate level work under moderate supervision. If I were an attorney, which may still happen, I would want the most competent and intelligent assistant I could find.

One way to be a great leader is to surround yourself with talented people. Perhaps if more lawyers and firms hired highly skilled staff, the perception of nonlawyers as incompetent and unknowledgable wastes of firm space would shift. However, most of the responsibility lies with paralegals and other nonlawyer staff. If intelligent, competent nonlawyer legal professionals are to be the rule, we have to keep insisting on more uniform standards among ourselves, and then uphold each other to those standards.

The overall trend is a positive one, and organizations like NALA (National Association of Legal Assistants) and NALS (National Association of Legal Professionals) are achieving goals step by step. One by one, state bar associations have started coming around, too. I'm optimistic that sooner, rather than later, anyone who sneers at the word "nonlawyer" or "paralegal" will be recognized by all as either insecure or out-of-place in the legal profession and that law will be seen by all of us as the team sport it truly is.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

A Major Overhaul... or Invasion of the Independent Paralegals!!

Robert Mongue, at The Empowered Paralegal blog, and I have been involved in a sideways dialogue of late regarding independent paralegals and UPL. His most recent post about independent paralegals, which can be found here, actually blew my mind a little bit. I thought I was reading an entry about independent paralegal practice, but I ended up diving head first into the Bellow-Sacks Access to Civil Legal Services Project, a broad access to justice project that has suggested, among other things, regulating limited nonlawyer practice in a few specialty areas of the law to achieve better access to legal remedies for indigent and even middle class citizens.

But this is not where the project either begins or ends. Its scope is so wide, and it so boldly threatens the ABA's monopoly on the legal world (or at least, it would appear that way at first - it would probably actually stregthen the positions of attorneys as leaders in their field by helping to fix the public's view of the legal system), that I imagine the best parts of it may never be implemented.

I have found three beautiful papers on this philosophy, two of which I share below. I wish I could express all of their findings and research-backed opinions in the small space I have here, but the most I can do is give you a list of highlights of each. However, I urge you to read them yourselves and join with me in this dialogue about how the legal community can rise to better serve the needs of individuals who need us.

In the first research-oriented paper I read on this subject, which I found at The Empowered Paralegal, the author makes the following points:

- Few lawyers tend to be interested in the areas of law in which low and middle income people need services, such as family law, debt, etc.
- Less than 17% of lawyers participate in pro bono programs, for various reasons.
- The United States Federal Administrative Procedure Act already authorizes qualified nonlawyers to appear before federal agencies to represent an individual.
- Several states, California and Washington included, already allow limited nonlawyer practice, to positive results.
- Pro se litigants could stand to benefit from the guidance of nonlawyer facilitators who could take them step by step through the legal process.
- Although critics suggest that in theory, offering nonlawyer legal services will diminish the quality of legal services to the public, existing evidence suggests the opposite may be true.
- In some other countries which allow nonlawyer practice, specifically England and Wales, lawyers had more cases that resulted in an inadequate rating of services, while nonlawyers had more cases that resulted in a rating of "excellent."
- In the U.S., what little comparative research we have on the topic suggests that nonlawyer specialists perform as well as lawyers. In fact, in a survey of consumer satisfaction with legal services, nonlawyer practitioners scored higher than attorneys. (There are various reasons for this, and I'm betting they don't include anything truly negative about lawyers, but rather how much consumers valued the services versus what they were charged for them.)
- UPL rules are overbroad: "Rather than sanction fraudulent legal service, the unauthorized practice doctrine prohibits lay practicioners from performing any traditional legal task."
- UPL rules "fail to fairly inform either the Independent Paralegal or the general public as to what conduct is prohibited."
- Case law shows that UPL laws in the U.S. have been relied on more heavily by members of the bar rather than by consumers, whom the laws are supposedly meant to protect.
- If nonlawyer specialists were narrowly regulated by licensing, minimum standards, etc., as opposed to broadly banned, the consumer would stand to benefit.
- UPL rules are based on the idea that laymen do not have the knowledge or ability to represent others in legal matters. But Independent Paralegals "develop not only competent, but highly specialized expertise by focusing on a specific area of the law or engaging in a certain type of assistance over time." And "[l]aw school does not teach some of the specialized legal knowledge that paralegals acquire from experience." (Or that knowledge attorneys acquire through experience, either.)
- By eliminating UPL rules and regulating highly specialized areas of nonlawyer practice, lower and middle income individuals would receive higher quality and more affordable legal services.

I am leaving out a ton of research and major points, of course, because the paper is so dense with information and thought0provoking discussion. The next piece of literature I found on the Bellow-Sacks project was much more practice-based, and provided a guide for the set-up for a form of socialized legal aid. You can read it here. Below I have listed a few of its highlights and proposals.

- Courts run better, and less time and money are spent when litigants are represented by attorneys, but not everyone can afford a lawyer.
- The Bellow-Sacks Access to Justice Project proposes the following: preventative legal aid, strong management and accountability, reforms that will reduce costs as well as the need for expert legal assistance, and private bar innovations to bring legal costs down.
- Not all legal needs are equal. Sometimes those who can least afford an attorney need assistance the most. (Think of indigent individuals who may be illegally and unfairly evicted or people living with spousal abuse.)
- Some legal issues do not inherently require the advice and expertise of a licensed, experienced attorney. (I know many of you will disagree with this; I'm just the messenger, this is a project created by highly educated attorneys.)
- The project proposes a "Service Pyramid" that involves, from base to tip, the following:
1) Web-based information;
2) Phone and web-based tools;
3) Brief service and advice with web-based tools;
4) Paralegals and lay-advisors; and finally
5) Law student and lawyers. Highly expert lawyers are at the tip top of the pyramid.

The purpose of the project's proposals and the focus of its research seems to be about finding a way to serve the poor and middle class with high quality legal services while at the same time allowing attorneys to take cases that will actually make money. This, as opposed to hoping more lawyers will give up the financial opportunies in order to provide free services to people who can't pay what their time is worth.

The project also includes co-pays, subsidies, and a lot of other things that give me great pause as to what kind of system it would set up; however, the idea is novel to me, and therefore intriguing.

Read the pieces, let me know what you think. I am itching to have a real discussion about the pros and cons of this type of legal system overhaul. I also would like to find out what happened to the project. Everything I find is from 2005 or earlier. I am sure bar associations didn't take kindly to it.

What I found most interesting about this project is that these ivy league education attorneys were promoting the idea of limited nonlawyer practice for the benefit of low to middle income people. They could probably command outrageous salaries at major firms (even in this economy), and yet they are not afraid of the ramifications of allowing nonlawyers to step in to handle those cases that highly educated attorneys don't want anyway.

If you have actually made it to the end of this entry, Reader, congratulations! I will reward you by stopping now.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

The Paralegal with Many Faces

The Boss recently surprised me with brand new, uber professional business cards. They look just like his, but with my name and designation as a certified paralegal NALA-style. I have worked for him for nearly two years, but this moment spoke to me in an I-am-here-to-stay kind of way. I definitely can't leave before using all of those business cards, at any rate.

As I read my card, with my title printed so clearly, I began thinking of all the things I do as the paralegal at our tiny firm. I am the clerical staff, the mail room, the coffee maker, the filer, the runner, the paralegal (of course), the notary public, and the receptionist. I take on all of these roles as the need arises, just like most people who work in small offices. The Boss, also, is not too proud to pour his own coffee, or to answer the phone when necessary. I've even caught him making copies before. This is the nature of a small office. When the population of the workplace constitutes the owner and his one employee, both are pretty self-sufficient.

Apparently the big firms require less effort from their attorneys when it comes to tasks that don't require a license. Our new neighbor, we'll call him Newbie, who just left a big firm and now works in the office above us, has convinced me of this. He had been with the big guys just long enough to forget how to function without the full support staff- paralegals, secretaries, IT professionals, etc. His current staff consists of his wife on a part-time basis until they learn that working together will result in one of their untimely deaths (very likely his own). But when she is not there, he relies from time to time on my expertise in certain areas, such as "where things go" when they are scanned into a computer.

It all began with a phone call last week asking me how to save a document as a PDF. I explained that we use CutePDFWriter. He ended up emailing me the documents so that I could save, convert, and email them back to him as PDFs. The next call came hours later, asking what kind of scanner the Boss has. The Boss and I both have all-in-one printer/copier/fax/scanners. I think they are fabulous. Newbie informed me that he already had a printer, so an all-in-one machine could get redundant. A few hours later, he returned with an all-in-one machine.

It was not long before another call came in.
"Do you have any extra USB cords down there?"
I checked. We didn't.
"My scanner didn't come a USB cord."

I went upstairs to examine the situation. He was right. His machine did not come with a USB cord. I think that's the way it is these days. The companies just expect you to have your own cord. "You'll have to buy one," I shrugged. But he needed to scan something that very moment. I asked if he had any USB cords hooked to something else that he could afford to go without for a bit. "Well," he hesitated, "I suppose I could unplug my printer's USB cord, at least for awhile." I tried not to smirk then as I asked, "Is there a reason you don't want to use your new all-in-one as your printer, too?"

But this is not where it ends, Reader. Once we had him up and running, I returned to my desk downstairs. I was right in the middle of recording an entry in my notary journal when the phone rang again. "When you scan something, where does it go?" I marched up the wooded stairs in my heels one more time to show him how to name a file and direct where it is to be saved. I'm sure this information was somewhere in a manual that came with the machine, but he did not appear to have time to look. I'm not sure the thought of a manual ever crossed his mind, actually. I suppose in big firms, IT is but a phone call away, and the secretary scans all of your documents for you.

The Boss just shook his head when I returned to our office. He was smirking, and I think I heard him mutter something about "fancy lawyers" when I walked past his door. As for me, I have one more title to add to my rather long list: IT Extraordinaire!

Monday, August 24, 2009

Where Are We Going?

I regret that I have been absent for a few days, Reader, but I am sure you will forgive me when you discover my reason. I was enjoying beautiful (and I do mean beautiful) Huntsville, Alabama this weekend with my boyfriend-the-lawyer. We enjoyed a long walk through an almost hidden park before bumping right into downtown Huntsville. We admired the mod-style courthouse in the middle of town befor exploring the local law offices. If only you could have seen it! We peeked into one window to an office that looked as if it had just stepped out of the 1960's. Dark wood, a grandfather clock, even a coat rack that should have been holding Don Draper's hat. I wanted to melt into the scene and be whisked away to a different time. As you can tell, my wish did not come true. Instead, I ended up back home in the southern part of the state, and four days gone on the blogging.

But even while away on my weekend mini-vacation, paralegal issues found me. First, if you have not checked out The Empowered Paralegal blog, by Robert E. Mongue, please do so now. Right now. Specifically, read this one about independent paralegals. Mr. Mongue received a letter from the owner of an independent paralegal business in Colorado regarding his business and how he avoids UPL. However, the description of this business, one which directly serves pro se litigants by assisting them in the process of representing themselves, gave me great pause.

My first thought was that a paralegal should be working under the supervision of a licensed and practicing attorney. Period. Then I took away the term paralegal and added in some generic term like project assistant. Then I started confusing myself. It is a given that you can represent yourself in a court of law if you so choose. You can draft and file documents and negotiate on your own behalf, if you so choose. What if you are a busy 8-5er and you need someone to assist you with the execution of your tasks? What if you will not ask this person for legal advice, nor will you expect them to use independent legal judgment - you just want them to help get everything typed up and filed? Is that person committing UPL?

My boyfriend-the-lawyer's answer was an unequivocal YES. His stance is that anyone who provides services of a legal nature without the supervision of a licensed practicing attorney is committing UPL. I certainly understand where he is coming from, and I agree. But not completely. California, for one, seems completely fine with allowing non-attorneys to help the general public with preparing and filing their legal documents. If you go to the website for the National Association of Legal Document Preparers, you will find a host of valuable information regarding this niche that several states seem intent on expanding for non-attorney practice.

I was quite surprised to read from their website that in 1993, the ABA actually commissioned a panel on non-lawyer practice, though their report never made it to the House of Delegates. From what I can gather, the report would have suggested regulating certain non-lawyer practices in order to provide less expensive access to justice for those who cannot afford attorneys.

Now, I know what lawyers will say about this. And I know how I, a fair-minded paralegal who does not wish to provide attorney-type services directly to the public, feel about it. If you keep pushing this issue into all fifty states, if lawyers eventually become merely the fine dining option when pursuing one's legal goals, wouldn't the license eventually become irrelevant, and then what would all those law school grads do with their expensive educations?

I jest, but I do agree with my boyfriend-the-lawyer (and not just because he takes me to see awesomely-bad chick flicks). There has to be a clearly defined line of UPL, and that line cannot keep being pushed further and further back until all the lawyers are confined to a tiny corner where they push and fight over expensive legal fees. The fact that the public, some non-attorneys, and even a few lawyers think that it is a good idea to regulate and allow non-attorney legal services directly to the public says at least one thing to me: lawyers have become too expensive for the common man. I think it also says that law firms value their own services more than their prospective clients do. When people are willing to forego the licensed professional for the regulated document preparer, it's time to rethink the status quo. Hey attorneys, do you hear me? It's your jobs and futures we're talking about here. It appears the paralegals will be just fine.

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Where Have All the Cowboys Gone?

I have been doing a lot of networking lately and gathering up CLE credits like candy. I have met some of the sweetest ladies and extremely professional women. I've spoken with everyone from the President of NALA to administrative professionals in the circuit clerk's office. I have learned that I have a hard time choosing between the organization in which most members are professional and career-concious and the organization in which most members are friendly and fun-loving. (As a result of this indecision, I'm choosing both.)

Through it all, though, one glaring reality has begun to emerge. The paralegal career field is missing a very large demographic - men. Where are all the men? Surely not every man who enjoys law decides he absolutely must be a lawyer... right? Or is it possible that the legal field is behind the medical field in yet another area - gender?

Even as society accepts and encourages women to attain higher education, get a law license, and practice in roles that were once traditionally held by only men, the same doesn't hold true for the positions widely held by females. This was once a problem with the nursing profession. As we all know, male nurses used to be a source of ridicule and fodder for unseemly jokes. Thank goodness the social tides have turned! As the nursing profession has shown just how important it is, as demand for nurses has grown on a national scale, as standards have continuously been raised, and as the nursing profession has offered increasing opportunities for career and educational growth, more and more men have flocked to the career.

Perhaps the legal field could take a cue from the world of medicine. Maybe it is time for legal professionals, licensed and not, to set higher standards for non-licensed legal professionals. Of course, it is all a matter of perspective on the whole. If paralegals raise the bar for our profession, we will implicitly invite into it individuals who are career-minded and looking for challenges. We will invite into it professionals who identify with their career and want to excel at something meaningful.

I think this is the key to recuiting more men into our profession. When we take ourselves seriously as a group, when we expect more from ourselves and co-workers, we will find others doing the same thing. Some of those individuals might even decide to join us. Some of them, let us hope, will be men.